SN/E Competition - SN1/E1 Competition
The Role of the Nucleophile in the SN1 / E1 Competition
In the SN1/E1 competition, the course of the reaction subsequent to the formation of the carbenium ion depends on the chemical character of the attacking reagent. Does the reagent act as a base in an E1 elimination or as a nucleophile in a SN1 reaction? A good nucleophile with relatively low basicity favours the SN1 reaction while a poor nucleophile favours an E1 elimination. In the E1 elimination, the proton need not necessarily be abstracted by the (poor) nucleophile (base). Instead, it may also be accepted by a solvent molecule. In principle, the reaction rate of the E1 elimination increases with the increasing basicity of the nucleophile. However, if stronger bases are applied, the E1 elimination is more and more superseded by the E2 elimination. Therefore, the E1 elimination normally occurs noticeably only with poor nucleophiles that have a low basicity, or if there is no nucleophile or base present (apart from the solvent). With increasing nucleophilicity, the SN1 reaction is favoured, while the E1 elimination is preferred with an increase in basicity.
The reaction center in the trigonal bipyramidal transition state of the SN2 reaction carries five substituents, while the central carbon of the SN1 reaction's transition state possesses just three substituents. Due to this, steric interactions are much less important in the latter. Nevertheless, there are obviously steric interactions between the carbenium ion and the attacking nucleophile in the transition state of the SN1 reaction. These are stronger than in E1 eliminations. Therefore, the E1 elimination may be preferred when the carbenium ion or the nucleophile contains bulky and sterically-demanding substituents.
The nucleophilicity of the nucleophile is determined by the well-known parameters. These are the basicity of the nucleophile and the electronegativity of the attacking atom, as well as the steric demand of the nucleophile's substituents. However, due to the reasons mentioned above, the influence of steric interactions on the nucleophilicity is smaller in SN1 reactions than it is in SN2 reactions.